An HR and payroll platform widely used by mid-sized Indian companies. That is a category description rather than a verdict. If it is doing what you need, the honest advice is to keep it — switching software is expensive and the gain has to be real.
A focused tool is usually better at its own job than a suite's equivalent module, and pretending otherwise would be silly. The question is not which is better at HR and payroll — it is what happens at the boundary. Keka ends where its job ends. That is a deliberate design choice and often the right one. The cost appears at the handover, where somebody re-enters what it holds into whatever comes next.
Ask both vendors the same thing: whether delivery and finance read the same personnel record, or receive an export of it. That is where the answers usually diverge, and it is worth more than any comparison table. Then ask what happens at the boundary. In Treepie the answer is one personnel record that Loop reads for availability, Books for cost and Desk for team membership. Ask Keka the equivalent, and ask what it costs to keep that answer true — an integration you maintain is part of the price.
There is no feature matrix here and no pricing comparison, and that is a choice rather than an omission. Both change faster than a page can be maintained, and a stale table about a named product is worse than none — it is confidently wrong about somebody else's business. Take Keka's current pricing and features from Keka, take ours from our pricing page, and compare them on the day you decide.
No, and this page does not argue that. It is a focused tool, and the comparison worth making is structural rather than a scorecard.
Because we cannot keep sixty-seven competitors' prices accurate, and publishing figures we cannot verify would be worse than publishing none. Check theirs with them on the day you decide.
Import maps a CSV and shows a full diff — creates, updates, duplicate matches and rejects — before anything commits. What takes the time is deciding what to bring, not the import.
Bring the tool you are trying to replace and half an hour of real records. We will tell you honestly which parts Nest does not improve.